Techcordance

Your Faith and Tech Review
Subscribe
  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Podcast Reviews
  • digital_Truth

Nature “writes back” to Behe Eight Years Later|Uncommon Descent

April 09, 2010 By: admin Category: Faith, Tech

Behe
Eight years ago, biochemist Michael Behe wrote this open letter to the prestigious scientific journal, Nature:

Sir-
As a public skeptic of the ability of Darwinian processes to account for complex cellular systems and a proponent of the hypothesis of intelligent design, (1) I often encounter a rebuttal that can be paraphrased as “no designer would have done it that way.” …
If at least some pseudogenes have unsuspected functions, however, might not other biological features that strike us as odd also have functions we have not yet discovered? Might even the backwards wiring of the vertebrate eye serve some useful purpose?
…. Hirotsune et al’s (3) work has forcefully shown that our intuitions about what is functionless in biology are not to be trusted.
Sincerely, Michael J. Behe
An Open Letter to Nature

Contrast that with Ken Miller’s now falsified claim in 1994:
the designer made serious errors, wasting millions of bases of DNA on a blueprint full of junk and scribbles.
Although Miller won in Judge Jones’ Kangaroo Court, Behe has won where it counts, in the court of empirical facts. Behe has won the argument over the backward wiring of the eye (see the essay by medical researcher Michael Denton: Inverted Retina).

And Behe has scored a second victory in the debate over junk DNA. Although Nature may not have had Behe in mind when they wrote the following, it seems, the net effect is as if they have “written back” eight years later to Behe and affirmed his views while essentially trashing their poster boy Ken Miller the honest Darwinist.
In Human genome at ten: Life is complicated, we read:
Just one decade of post-genome biology has exploded that view. Biology’s new glimpse at a universe of non-coding DNA — what used to be called ‘junk’ DNA — has been fascinating and befuddling. Researchers from an international collaborative project called the Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (ENCODE) showed that in a selected portion of the genome containing just a few per cent of protein-coding sequence, between 74% and 93% of DNA was transcribed into RNA2. Much non-coding DNA has a regulatory role; small RNAs of different varieties seem to control gene expression at the level of both DNA and RNA transcripts in ways that are still only beginning to become clear. “Just the sheer existence of these exotic regulators suggests that our understanding about the most basic things — such as how a cell turns on and off — is incredibly naive,” says Joshua Plotkin, a mathematical biologist at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia

Promtional Video:

One Response to “ Nature “writes back” to Behe Eight Years Later|Uncommon Descent ”

  1. # 1 Wavatar Tweets that mention Techcordance | Nature “writes back” to Behe Eight Years Later|Uncommon Descent -- Topsy.com Says:
    April 12th, 2010 at 5:53 pm

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Joe S. Joe S said: http://techcordance.com/2010/04/09/nature-writes-back-to-behe-eight-years-lateruncommon-descent/ [...]

← Physicians help parents, schools combat propaganda|OneNewsNow
Half of America ‘effectively on welfare’|OneNewsNow →
  • Post Categories

  • Podcast Reviews

    Skeptiod

    Skeptoid podcast by Brian Dunning is an interesting debunker of commonly held misconceptions about a variety of subjects. While secular in nature Mr. Dunning does attempt to be fair to religious points of view from a materialists perspective. It is very interesting an enlightening.
    Podcast Reviews

  • RSS FoxNewsRadio

    • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
  • POWERED BY UBUNTU

    image widget
  • Compassion International

    Help, in the name of Christ. Compassion International
  • Faith

    • APM: Speaking of Faith with Krista Tippett
    • Bible Gateway
    • Bornagain Radio
    • Calvary Chapel
    • Center for Christ and Culture
    • Christian Films
    • Chuck Missler
    • Compassion Int.
    • Crosswalk
    • Desiring God Sermon Video
    • Focus on the Family Radio
    • Gospel.com
    • Insight For Living Daily Broadcast
    • Just Thinking (RZIM)
    • Let My People Think (RZIM)
    • Ligoniers
    • Point of View Radio Talk Show
    • Reasons to Believe Creation Update
    • Sermon Illustrations
    • The C. S. Lewis Foundation
    • The Discovery Inst.
    • The Hal Lindsey Report
    • World Magazine
  • Tech

    • CNET News Daily Podcast from CNET
    • Cranky Geeks H.264 Video
    • Discovery News (Video)
    • ExtremeTech.com
    • Find Podcasts
    • Jupiter Broadcasting » Linux Action Show – MP3
    • Linux Journal
    • Linux Reality — Main Feed (All)
    • NOVA Vodcast | PBS
    • NPR: Science Friday Podcast
    • PCMag Radio
    • Slashdot Review – SDR News
    • Systm (Small Quicktime)
    • tech5
    • Tekzilla (Large Quicktime)
    • The Linux Link Tech Show Itunes Feed
    • this WEEK in TECH – MP3 Edition
    • WAMU: The Kojo Nnamdi Show: Tech Tuesday Podcast
  • Calendar

    April 2010
    S M T W T F S
    « Mar   May »
     123
    45678910
    11121314151617
    18192021222324
    252627282930  
  • Recent Comments

      Wavatar
    • admin on Study: Net Neutrality Rules Would Cost Telecom Jobs|PCWorld
    • Wavatar
    • Lonely Conservative on Study: Net Neutrality Rules Would Cost Telecom Jobs|PCWorld
    • Wavatar
    • Techcordance | Half of America ‘effectively on Welfare ‘|Onenewsnow on Half of America ‘effectively on welfare’|OneNewsNow
    • Wavatar
    • Tweets that mention Techcordance | Nature “writes back” to Behe Eight Years Later|Uncommon Descent -- Topsy.com on Nature “writes back” to Behe Eight Years Later|Uncommon Descent
    • Wavatar
    • Rudolf Skutnik on Disney Disses YouTube by Taking Content To Hulu|TopTech News
  • Thanks to Bert Jerred for our theme sound.
    image widget
  • Verse of the Day

    “Jesus replied, "If anyone loves me, he will obey my teaching. My Father will love him, and we will come to him and make our home with him.”

    Brought to you by BibleGateway.com. Copyright (C) NIV. All Rights Reserved. (John 14:23, NIV)

  • Tech History

    -Radar-

    History of Radar

    Heinrich Hertz in Germany calculated that an electric current swinging very rapidly back and forth in a conducting wire would radiate electromagnetic waves into the surrounding space (today we would call such a wire an "antenna"). With such a wire he created (in 1886) and detected such oscillations in his lab, using an electric spark, in which the current oscillates rapidly (that is how lightning creates its characteristic crackling noise on the radio!). Today we call such waves "radio waves". At first however they were "Hertzian waves, " and even today we honor the memory of their discoverer by measuring frequencies in Hertz (Hz), oscillations per second--and at radio frequencies, in megahertz (MHz).

  • Techcordance on Twitter

    Follow Techcordance on Twitter
  • Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • WordPress.org
  • GOOGLE

  • Pages

    • About
    • Archives
    • digital_Truth
    • Podcast Reviews
  • Archives

  • Recent Posts

    • Ground Zero Mosque: Olive Branch or ‘Soft Jihad’?|CBN
    • What Facebook Doesn’t Tell You About Privacy|PCWorld
    • Franklin Graham: Christians Will Lose the Power to Pray Outside Church Walls ‘Maybe in My Lifetime’|CNSNews
    • Fla. School District Sued over Prayer Constraint|The Christian Post
    • Facebook’s new features secretly add apps to your profile|Yahoo News
  • Christian Podcast Directory - Audio and Video Godcasting PodcastAlley.com Feeds Techcordance Feed Shark hwy777 PODBLASTER
  • Tags

    abortion Acedemia Add new tag Apologetics choice Christian computers Congress Current Events Democrat Entertainment Facebook Faith Google Islam Judiciary Library of Congress Movies News NYC Obama podcast Politics Privacy Religion Republicans Science Social Networking Spirituality Tech Washington
  • New on Techcordance...

    • earthquake tremor CNY? 2010-06-23
    • More updates...

    Posting tweet...

    Powered by Twitter Tools.



Techcordance © 2007 All Rights Reserved. Using WordPress 2.9.2 Engine
Entries and Comments.

Prosumer 1.4 made by Nurudin Jauhari


Theme Tweaker by Unreal
This site employs the Wavatars plugin by Shamus Young.